Tap a type, then enter your town or state to see the closest shops by name.
Tap a type above to start.
The classic hard-scooped American cone
This is what most people mean by "ice cream": a cream, milk and sugar base churned with air, hardened in a freezer, then scooped from a dipping cabinet. Under U.S. rules, anything sold as ice cream needs at least 10% milkfat. Small-batch shops usually go well above that, often 14–18% for "premium" and "super-premium" styles, and whip in less air, so a pint feels heavy and the scoop is rich and dense.
Artisan shops make their base in-house and change flavors with the season. Ask what's made on-site; that's where the best flavors usually are.
Italian, dense, served a little warmer
Gelato uses more milk and less cream than American ice cream, so it usually has less butterfat (roughly 4–9%). It's churned slowly so it takes in very little air, and it's kept warmer than hard ice cream. That's why gelato is smooth and stretchy, and why the flavor hits harder: your tongue isn't numbed by the cold, and there's less fat coating it.
There's no U.S. legal definition of gelato, so quality varies. Good signs: flat metal pans or covered pozzetti tins instead of heaped-up mounds, natural colors (pistachio should be olive-brown, not bright green), and a flat spade instead of a round scoop. Most gelaterias also make dairy-free sorbetto.
Ice cream plus egg yolk, made fresh all day
Frozen custard is ice cream with egg yolk added. U.S. rules require at least 1.4% egg yolk solids, and the yolk makes it richer, smoother and a pale yellow. Custard stands run it out of special machines that add very little air and make small batches through the day, so it's served soft and fresh rather than hardened in a freezer.
It's a Midwest institution (Milwaukee calls itself the custard capital) and a Jersey Shore boardwalk staple. Look for a "flavor of the day" board; many stands rotate one special next to vanilla and chocolate.
Twists, dips and the roadside dairy bar
Soft serve comes straight out of a machine that freezes and whips the mix as you order, so it's never hardened. Most soft-serve mixes are lower in fat than hard ice cream, often in the single digits, which is why some well-known chains can't legally call theirs "ice cream". The air and the warmer serving temperature give it that light, smooth swirl.
This is the home of the twist cone, the chocolate dip, the Blizzard-style mix-in and the seasonal walk-up dairy bar. Many dairy bars open in spring and close for winter, so check hours before you drive out.
Tangy, cultured and usually self-serve
Frozen yogurt starts with cultured milk, which gives it a tangy edge plain ice cream doesn't have. It's usually lower in fat, though not always lower in sugar. Most froyo shops are self-serve: you pull your own flavors and pay by weight after the toppings bar.
There's no federal standard for frozen yogurt, so the amount of live cultures varies a lot from brand to brand. If that matters to you, ask whether the base is made with live and active cultures.
No dairy, by recipe or by choice
Sorbet is fruit (or coffee, chocolate, even wine), sugar and water, churned like ice cream but with no dairy at all. Don't confuse it with sherbet, which does contain a little milk: U.S. rules put sherbet at 1–2% milkfat. Vegan ice cream goes further and copies real ice cream's creaminess with oat, coconut, cashew or almond bases.
If you're avoiding dairy for an allergy rather than a preference, ask about shared scoops, wells and machines. Many shops keep a separate scoop for dairy-free flavors if you ask.
Water ice, shave ice, snow cones and raspados
These are the ice-based treats: no cream, all refreshment. Italian ice (Philadelphians call it water ice) is fruit, sugar and water frozen while it's stirred, so it's smooth and scoopable, somewhere between sorbet and a slush. Shaved ice, the Hawaiian "shave ice", is a block of ice shaved into powder-fine flakes that soak up flavored syrup. Snow cones use coarser crushed ice, New Orleans snoballs sit in between, and Mexican raspados often add fresh fruit, chamoy or condensed milk.
Order a "gelati" at many Italian ice shops and you'll get it layered with soft serve or custard.
Thai-style, made in front of you
Rolled ice cream comes from Thailand's street-food stalls. A liquid base goes onto a steel plate chilled far below freezing; the server chops in your mix-ins (fruit, cookies, cereal) with two spatulas, spreads it thin, then scrapes it up into tight rolls. Every cup is made to order, so expect a few minutes' wait and a show.
Because nothing is churned, there's almost no air in it. Rolls are dense and melt slowly at first.
| Style | Base | Fat | Air | How it's served |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ice cream | Cream, milk, sugar | 10%+ by law | Medium | Hard-scooped, coldest |
| Gelato | More milk, less cream | About 4–9% | Low | Spaded, warmer |
| Frozen custard | Ice cream base + egg yolk | 10%+, ≥1.4% yolk | Very low | Fresh from the machine |
| Soft serve | Lighter dairy mix | Usually 3–6% | Medium–high | Swirled from the machine |
| Frozen yogurt | Cultured milk | Low to none | Medium | Self-serve swirl |
| Sherbet | Fruit + a little dairy | 1–2% | Medium | Scooped |
| Sorbet | Fruit, sugar, water | None | Low | Scooped |
| Italian ice | Fruit, sugar, water | None | Low | Scooped, smooth |
| Shaved ice | Shaved block ice + syrup | None | n/a | Shaved to order |
| Rolled | Liquid base, frozen on a plate | Varies | Very low | Made to order |
Fat figures for ice cream, frozen custard and sherbet are the U.S. FDA standards of identity (21 CFR Part 135). Other figures are typical ranges; recipes vary by shop.
Mochi ice cream: small balls of ice cream wrapped in sweet rice dough. Kulfi: dense South Asian frozen dessert made from slowly reduced milk, often flavored with cardamom, saffron or pistachio. Paletas: Mexican ice pops, either water-based or creamy, packed with real fruit. Dondurma: stretchy Turkish ice cream thickened with salep and mastic. You'll usually find these at specialty shops listed under the styles above. See our guide to frozen desserts for more.